Mindful eating? Intutive Eating? Normal Eating? yes Yes YES!
General, Low Stress Weight Loss January 17th, 2008Where do some of the ideas in Low Stress Weight Loss come from?
Mainly from my own history and my own successes and failures. But I have always read a LOT of diet books and magazines and listened to podcasts, and read blogs etc too - to keep up the motivation. But that kind of intensity is exhausting, and rapidly crosses the border from “interest” to “obsession”.
The biggest guideline for “Low Stress Weight Loss” is to eliminate the stress I’ve so often felt while attempting to lose weight. So out go the daily weigh-ins, out goes calorie counting, out goes long frequent sessions at the gym. And I’ve also radically cut back on my reading diet books and magazines, and listening to diet-and-fitness podcasts. Basically aside from this blog and seeing Dr Hope every 2 weeks, I’m just on my own.
That said, a lot of my approach is based on what I’ve learned over the years. There are a few books that have had a substantial influence on my current thinking, and some books and websites that go in the same direction. To be clear - I’m not following any of these plans specifically, but I think there are some good ideas in a lot of them, and some of those ideas are similar to what I’m working on.
There are two books that have had a pretty major influence on me. The first is “The Path of Least Resistance”, by Robert Fritz, which is a general self-help book I bought and read maybe 15 years ago. The basic premise is that your life will go in the direction that you make to be the easiest for you. So if you want to change something you need to think about all the things that keep you where you are so you can build new ways into your life to go in a new direction. I got this book for reasons having NOTHING to do w my weight, but I’ve applied the principles to job, weight, relationship, etc - and I think reading this book fundamentally affected the way I looked at personal change.
A more recent book I can recommend is “Mindless Eating” by Brian Wansink. I bought this book because it seemed interesting (a mix of psychology and marketing), not really for “diet” reasons. He is a university guy who runs a food center at Cornell where they do a lot of the work that is behind the manipulative packaging and context of eating - or more to the point, overeating. His book kind of walks you through the way portions, context, etc contribute to overeating, and he made an attempt to make it diet-y by adding some mild suggestions of how you can incorporate that knowledge to change your behavior and lose weight. Because it’s not a typical diet book perspective and the ‘diet’ hand is pretty light it’s refreshing. And it was maybe the first time I saw anyone write down that making a few small changes you could lose 1-2 pounds a month pretty painlessly but that over time that would really add up. So the idea sat in the back of my head for a few months until I was again unhappy w my weight and ready to do something about it, and that’s when it kind of cemented for me - so I’d say his book was a major influence, even if not directly.
A few months ago when I started all this I was looking for some more understanding and found on the web several sources that talk about “intuitive eating” and it’s twins (”mindful” and “normal”). I haven’t read books on the topic or spent more than a few minutes finding sites and bookmarking them, but I thought I’d share some of what I found for those who are looking to explore this type of approach further.
My personal issues aren’t really binge-eating, nor do I feel the least bit receptive to Overeaters Anonymous, but both of those topics have lots of info in the same vein, and a lot of people seem to find them helpful. I also tend to avoid the “emotional eating” stuff, because I am someone who tends to put more emphasis on BEHAVIOR than anything else, and what I’ve stumbled upon on emotional eating hasn’t really pushed my buttons.
Of what I’ve found online and liked, the most popular seems to be “Intuitive Eating” by Tribole & Resch, who have written a book (which I don’t have and haven’t read) but they have good (and free) info on their website : http://www.intuitiveeating.com/
The other search term I had success with is “normal eating” where there are a few authors and “mindful eating” where again there are a few authors. Here is a link to a mindful eating site http://www.tcme.org/patientNewsletter.htm
January 17th, 2008 at 1:05 pm
Thank you for the links Round. I’ve been really interested in mindful eating since I read about it in some of your earlier entries. I love how you can take what you’ve learned in these books and apply them to your life. Kudos to you! *hugs*
January 17th, 2008 at 2:20 pm
I think the difference between normal and mindful eating in my mind is that on my WW diet I can eat “normal” cause I don’t eat fake foods, or liquid diet. But I have to train myself to be mindful. I have to be conscious of what I eat, how much I eat and why I am eating. The big one with me is WHY I eat, and so often it is an emotional response to something, boredom, pain, anger or even just habit. So I now stop and ask myself, “do I really need that?” And most often I will say, “no” and walk away whereas before I never questioned, I would have just eaten that chocolate or pizza even if not hungry or even if I didn’t not really want it.
That is what the blogs and my friends here have given me. So many different ideas and thoughts, I would never have questioned WHY I ate before I came to the blogs, and now I find that has become part of my daily life, my daily balance.
Now mindful eating is a part of my life, so I now can eat normally and mindfully. Wow!
January 17th, 2008 at 3:16 pm
I only had a chance to skim it, but I like the intuitive eating site. When you read, it just kind of hits you like, “Why did I think it was so hard?” Years of conditioning from childhood on up is what makes concept of intuitive eating so hard to grasp.
Thanks for the links! I know I’ll be visiting the intuitive eating site, again, for more in depth reading.
January 17th, 2008 at 4:19 pm
All this stuff is so common-sensical, but so easy to stray from. It’s a real eye-opener when I realize (oh, yes - I have to remind myself from time to time) I’m the one creating the roadblocks in my life!
January 17th, 2008 at 5:54 pm
That mindless eating book looks very interesting. I will have to see if my library has it. Thanks for sharing!I’m going to check out that intuitive eating site as soon as the baby goes to sleep.
January 17th, 2008 at 7:47 pm
nice job round. appreciate the links. I think we call all agree, we know what we have to do, it’s doing it that is tough. I have read quite a bit about the subconscious mind and it really has a hold on us. It doesn’t change without a fight. Thats why we fall back to old habits, when we feel weak. The concept of being mindful, in general, is over-ridng the subconscious. Tough to do, but with the practice of mindfulness, we are creating new habits and the subconscious has no choice but to surrender.
Sandy
January 17th, 2008 at 9:20 pm
I think mindful eating and normal eating might be something I should look into. I have the mindful part down, but not the normal. I would also give all of China (if I owned it) to not be tied to the scale like I am. You barely weigh yourself and you are much happier for it. Keep doing your thing, and I’ll try to work on not weighing myself everyday. Thanks for the recommendations, I should really check out those books…
January 17th, 2008 at 10:28 pm
Thanks for the links! I had a smile moment when I read the first item under What’s Intuitive Eating: (1) Reject the Diet Mentality! LOL. Just when I was getting back into my points counting again! Seriously, it’s great to remember mindfulness, perhaps especially when counting points. Food isn’t really about numbers, but about taste, health, enjoyment, and satisfaction.
January 18th, 2008 at 12:06 am
It does seem like an interesting concept, and it sounds like it’s working for you. Although I track my calories, in theory, I deny myself nothing. I do try and think before I eat it, and I may adjust the rest of my day to have something I want. I do think eventually I can drop the calories once I have a better idea of how I’m eating.
January 18th, 2008 at 6:02 am
I think you’re right about not following plans to a T. I mean, I’m following the idea of the South Beach Diet, but I’m honestly not following it to every single guideline. Like my rice cakes are most likely not allowed, but I eat them anyway! We all just need to figure out what works for US and everyone is different. Some fad diets and books do work for some people…but a lot of the time they’re not customized enough to please everyone’s lifestyle.
January 18th, 2008 at 6:38 am
I wish I was not a scale (aka Meaner) addict…but I am…hopelessly I’m afraid!! I will try to do better!!!
Best of luck on your new adventures!!
Judy
January 18th, 2008 at 2:21 pm
Eliminating stress?? Can I kill them if I get a signed consent form from their parents?!!
January 18th, 2008 at 4:52 pm
I really enjoy your new take on weight loss! I think that even if it takes longer to achieve your goal once there it will stick and you’ll be much happier all along the way too. Thanks for all the links they are very helpful and were able to give me a greater insight into what makes eat what I eat. Anyways, THANKS!
January 19th, 2008 at 5:03 am
I’ve heard about Mindless Eating from other sources as well, as a generally good book. I must look into getting it!
January 20th, 2008 at 9:22 pm
Thanks for your motivating comment on my blog
I think your approach to weight loss is great. I can definitely learn a few things from you. I have anxiety problems, and reading this entry made me rethink my approach. Thank you
January 21st, 2008 at 4:33 pm
If you want low stress just eat away all of your stress. All it takes is a couple of twinkies… just kidding.